SEO Myth Tested: Buying Expired Domain For SEO ( What to Expect?)

Many SEO bloggers preach for the acquisition of organic traffic by acquiring expired domains. Is it working? Not so sure!

Why buying expired domains?

A quite compelling post by Nathan Gotch shows how you can get many highly relevant backlinks if you buy relevant expired domains.

What are Expired Domains?

Expired domains are domain names that have existed and have not been renewed by their owner.

Those websites might have acquired many backlinks over time, hence the idea that you could increase your authority by redirecting those websites to your own domain.

Test Methodology

I was deeply intrigued by the idea, so I decided to test it on a small scale.

1. Found All Clients With Low Traffic But High Authority

I quick listed all governmental institutions because they have super high authority, the don’t care of their own SEO, and a lot of them changed their domain name at that time when they all migrated to “.qc.ca” ccTLDs.

Then, it was easy to find a domain that only have been dropped for a few days.

2. Bought an Expired Governmental Institution Domain

So, I finally found one on Godaddy that didn’t renew their website, and that was bringing us next to zero traffic from their own profile on our website.

3. Redirected The Domain to The Client Profile

At this point, I am quite certain that the client profile was a super relevant landing page to the newly acquired domain name.

It had the client’s name as a header, the client’s own description in the context of the page, and the client’s logo.

Redirecting the domain to their own Facebook page wouldn’t have been more relevant.

So, I made a Redirect 301 of every relevant pages that were still getting traffic from Google.

Expired Domain Acquisition Results

I have to say, the result of this test isn’t surprising.

Everything was there for success:

  • High Authority Expired Domain
  • Expired for a Week Only
  • Plenty Of Backlinks
  • Easy To Track Marginal Gains
  • Super Relevant Landing Page

Even on a small scale such as this, I am fairly conviced that the marginal gains are not worth the risk of doing this at scale.

Expired Domain Acquisition Results

What happened is this.

The week after the domain acquisition, I saw a huge increase in organic traffic to that page. Most traffic came from branded terms (the client’s branded terms).

After two weeks, I completely stopped receiving organic traffic, coming back to the initial state.

In the same period, I also lost most gained impressions in Google Search Console.

Organic Impressions of the expired Domain and the Client URL

Disclaimer

I have to say this: I don’t believe this to be a true scientific experiment.

The results being se clear cut and so close to what I expected, I don’t plan on repeating the experiment, and I don’t pretend that I have provided any absolute proof.

I’ve just gathered the information that I needed to drop the domain name that I have acquired and abandon this as a viable SEO strategy.

Tl;DR

This is nothing against Nathan Gotch work which I believe is really interesting and is worth reading.

One man’s meat is another man’s poison

This post is at best a proof that something that works in an industry, may, or may not, be as good, or even adverse in another one.

It is my little cry out to the community to make sure to make proper test and stop believing everything you read online, even from credible SEO sources.